ZitatQuestion
What must one do as a judge if a player activates either of this effects, and when they resolve, he/she finds out they don't have the appropiate card in their decks?
Return the game to the previous state (if possible) give the player a (minor????) penalty and ask him/her to shuffle the deck?
ZitatAlles anzeigenAnswer
That would be my goal, if at all possible.
Working on the assumption that this was simply a mistake, I would try to repair the game state as best I am able. Usually we have some general idea of what is left in our Deck, but there will be times where we play before we think. How you repair the gamestate, when possible, will really depend on the situation and what card(s) has/have been played.
If I were to activate "Mystic Tomato's" effect, thinking I still had someone I could bring out, and it turned out I was wrong, it might be better to just have the effect disappear and very briefly verify that no monster could be Special Summoned. If we're talking about a Spell Card someone activated, returning it to its previous state may work best.
Curtis Schultz
UDE Netrep
CurtisSchultz_Netrep@hotmail.com
"Hey you in the pyramid! The Spirit of Zoma welcomes you!"
Er hat doch eh in dem Forum schon geantwortet
ZitatOriginal von Campernator
Er hat doch eh in dem Forum schon geantwortet
Wer lesen kann ist hier deutlich im Vorteil:
Zitatso was wäre die strafe für eine fehlaktivierung? gibt es überhaupt eine?
Wenn du - Campernator - mir nun sagen kannst, wo Curtis die Frage beantwortet hat, dann ziehe ich meinen Hut vor dir - als qualifizierter "Zwischen-den-Zeilen-Leser." :P
Nun aber zur eigentlichen Frage:
Es handelt sich hier um eine ganz normale Fehlaktivierung. Normalerweise wird man lediglich dann auf einem Turnier
darauf hingewiesen, dass die Aktivierung eine Fehlaktivierung war und es gibt dann eigentlich keine Strafe.
Laut UDE Policies jedoch sollte man als Schiedsrichter des Turniers eine Verwarnung geben, denn jeder Spieler
sollte schon qualifiziert genug sein um sein Deck zu kennen.
Hier nochmal der Auszug:
P-13 Procedural Error—Minor (Penalty: Warning)
This penalty is appropriate for a minor, unintentional, and easily fixable infraction that a player commits during the course of a tournament.
The damage to the game state is easily repaired, so the penalty is minimal in all cases.
This is an appropriate penalty to use when a player unintentionally plays a card incorrectly and causes a minor game disruption.
M-F-G
Kaiba